Latest News

The results are in for our 2026 Ethical Investment Screening Questionnaire!

You probably know the drill by now! Every year, we ask our Thomas and Thomas ‘Pro-Ethical’ Clients how they feel about our screening process.

Ethical screening is a layer of research and analysis that we carry out on our own ethical model portfolios every quarter without fail. During this process, we carefully analyse all of the underlying ethical policies published by the fund managers within our portfolios. This enables us to check that our clients’ collective ethical investment goals are being met.

We start with ‘negative screening’ which considers the areas our clients want to avoid – and then look at the ‘positive screening’ which considers areas our clients collectively want to support.
Our overarching objective is to hold the fund managers that we recommend to account against the common ground our clients provide us with.

That is why our annual ethical screening questionnaire is so vital.

Let’s face it – the past 12 months with a Trump administration has pushed investment in areas such as Oil and Armaments. Ethical portfolios have struggled to keep up with this one-dimensional market. It has felt like the world has gone backwards by 20 years.

This has led some investors to walk away from ethical investments, whilst others have taken the longer view that they don’t wish to profit from investments that harm the environment or society. We don’t judge either way – our job is simply to work with the remit that we are given. That is the beauty of being truly independent.

We started by asking the same negative screening questions – using the smart survey tool. This prompted our clients to make a ‘quick fire’ selection to prioritize areas that they wanted to avoid with their portfolio.

Once again, our clients collectively wanted to avoid investments that had any connection to poor human rights or oppressive regimes. The second most popular concern was a tie between Pornography and Unsustainable Deforestation. Finally in third place was Gambling.

The big surprise for us was the collective selection of Gambling as a really important negative screen – above tobacco, animal testing and fossil fuels. This was a really interesting result.
We then asked our clients about the areas they would like to support.

Living in Pembrokeshire, it was no surprise to see investments that help eradicate ‘Ocean Waste’ take first place – with addressing ‘Climate Change’ a close second. ‘Sustainable Forestry’ was also high on the list of areas that clients would like to see as an investment solution.

Finally, we asked a bonus question! We made a statement: ‘I would tolerate the inclusion of some non-ethical stocks such as fossil fuels or armaments to improve performance potential’. We then asked clients to score how much they either agreed or disagreed with the statement across five bands.

The answers were really mixed, with around 43.5% agreeing or strongly agreeing and 36% disagreeing or strongly disagreeing. Some 20.5% were stuck in the middle – unsure which way to go. This was fascinating.

As usual, our wonderful respondents were very generous with their comments. We really felt your love and appreciated it!

However, we also gleaned a lot from the comments boxes. It was clear that some clients firmly do not want us to change our strict ethical screening strategy – even if it affects performance. Whilst others would happily accept some inclusion of armaments and possibly fossil fuels.

Several clients were unhappy about investment that included the United States – but they equally understood it was impractical to completely avoid the US.

My view after reading all of the responses was that we know the biggest areas our clients collectively want to avoid – and we know the areas they collectively want to try and support. It’s the stuff in the middle that perhaps we need to discuss some more with them!

For now, we will stick to the same screening process – but we will continue to enjoy our individual conversations at our client annual reviews.

If you would like to chat a bit more about your Ethical portfolio – please just give us a call. We love to help and we have got options for you!

Our best wishes as ever. Darren and the team.

Brochure

Download our Welcome to the Family Brochure

Download our short ethical brochure to get a good idea of our approach and offerings.

Download